|author||David Abbott <firstname.lastname@example.org>||2016-10-16 16:17:58 -0400|
|committer||David Abbott <email@example.com>||2016-10-16 16:17:58 -0400|
|parent||added log for 2016/09 trustee meeting (diff)|
added log and motions from Oct meeting
2 files changed, 280 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/2016/meeting-20161016-log.txt b/2016/meeting-20161016-log.txt
new file mode 100644
@@ -0,0 +1,279 @@
+Oct 16 15:06:10 * prometheanfire bangs the virtual gavel, the meeting for the 16th of October 2016 is open
+Oct 16 15:06:24 <prometheanfire> Roll call
+Oct 16 15:06:28 <dabbott> here
+Oct 16 15:06:35 <antarus> here
+Oct 16 15:07:17 <prometheanfire> robbat2, SwifT?
+Oct 16 15:07:29 <dabbott> SwifT: will not make it today, work stuff
+Oct 16 15:07:59 <prometheanfire> k, robbat2?
+Oct 16 15:09:11 <prometheanfire> gonna give one more minute then move on, still have a minimal quorum with just us
+Oct 16 15:09:13 <antarus> text him?
+Oct 16 15:10:01 <prometheanfire> don't have is number
+Oct 16 15:10:26 <antarus> you should in your email
+Oct 16 15:10:27 <antarus> I'll send him one
+Oct 16 15:10:31 <antarus> but we can begin w/p
+Oct 16 15:10:33 <antarus> er w/o
+Oct 16 15:11:23 <prometheanfire> Old Business - Activity Tracker
+Oct 16 15:11:52 <prometheanfire> there's been some updates just to bring it up to date, but no actions have been taken that I know of
+Oct 16 15:12:08 <antarus> (sms sent)
+Oct 16 15:12:20 <prometheanfire> IRS Status Report - will wait for robbat2
+Oct 16 15:12:24 <antarus> Can we put a link to the tracker in the /topic?
+Oct 16 15:12:31 <antarus> I always forget where it is
+Oct 16 15:12:43 <antarus> or is in the agenda
+Oct 16 15:12:54 <dabbott> its in the agenda
+Oct 16 15:12:57 <antarus> ahh it is, excellent
+Oct 16 15:12:59 <prometheanfire> :D
+Oct 16 15:13:04 <antarus> thanks dabbott ;)
+Oct 16 15:13:23 <dabbott> you are welcome :)
+Oct 16 15:13:30 <prometheanfire> while we wait we can discuss the presidency or move to induct new members
+Oct 16 15:13:39 <prometheanfire> might be better to do the later first while we wait
+Oct 16 15:13:55 <dabbott> I don't see anything major in the tracker
+Oct 16 15:13:56 <antarus> the latter seems the best course of action
+Oct 16 15:14:34 <prometheanfire> Membership Applications - Mauricio Lima Pilla (pilla)
+Oct 16 15:14:39 <prometheanfire> Aye
+Oct 16 15:14:49 <dabbott> yes
+Oct 16 15:15:36 <antarus> aye
+Oct 16 15:16:10 <prometheanfire> carried with min of 3
+Oct 16 15:16:19 <dabbott> I will send the email and update the members list
+Oct 16 15:16:28 <prometheanfire> thanks
+Oct 16 15:18:00 <prometheanfire> moving on from that, my stuff
+Oct 16 15:18:13 <prometheanfire> prometheanfire - D&O insurance Bug 592198
+Oct 16 15:18:15 <willikins> https://bugs.gentoo.org/592198 "D&O insurance"; Gentoo Foundation, Proposals; CONF; prometheanfire:trustees
+Oct 16 15:18:58 <prometheanfire> It took a while but I found the provider used by the PSF, I have not asked for info / quotes yet though but will by the next meeting
+Oct 16 15:20:53 <antarus> ok, my general opinion is we should get some pending price and terms
+Oct 16 15:21:00 <antarus> so no action required until we get price and terms? :)
+Oct 16 15:21:05 <prometheanfire> correct
+Oct 16 15:21:15 <antarus> sgtm
+Oct 16 15:21:25 <prometheanfire> it was my intention to get a quote / terms and vote on it in the next meeting
+Oct 16 15:21:39 <antarus> seems reasonable
+Oct 16 15:21:44 <dabbott> I can go either way for $500 I would say ok if the others want it, if it gets costly, no
+Oct 16 15:22:05 <prometheanfire> dabbott: I think I feel about the same
+Oct 16 15:22:11 <dabbott> thanks for the research prometheanfire
+Oct 16 15:22:25 <prometheanfire> ya, it's slow going, totally new area for me
+Oct 16 15:22:42 <prometheanfire> next?
+Oct 16 15:23:02 * prometheanfire prepares to open the floodgates
+Oct 16 15:23:05 <antarus> swift is not here, robin is not here, you want to talk about metastructure or president?: )
+Oct 16 15:23:14 <prometheanfire> meta first
+Oct 16 15:23:44 <prometheanfire> president I hope to be simpler, but as we are only discussing metastructure I think it's better to do that now then make a decision now
+Oct 16 15:23:57 <prometheanfire> prometheanfire - Robbat2's email (moving comrel, infra and pr under foundation)
+Oct 16 15:24:15 <prometheanfire> I don't think we should talk about moving projects immediately
+Oct 16 15:24:23 <prometheanfire> rich0: ping
+Oct 16 15:24:42 <dabbott> we have a hard time getting people involved with a simple set-up more complex, who is going to oversee it, I like less structure not more imho
+Oct 16 15:24:50 <antarus> I'm trying to understand approximately what this proposal is trying to accomplish
+Oct 16 15:25:24 <antarus> for reference: https://archives.gentoo.org/gentoo-project/message/d679e40f31dc2341b534834540d504b1
+Oct 16 15:26:14 <antarus> dabbott: I think its tricky because the existing groups have annoying rules for joining already
+Oct 16 15:26:18 <antarus> but they are just poorly documented
+Oct 16 15:26:26 <antarus> infra for example, has always had "weird" rules
+Oct 16 15:26:33 <prometheanfire> I think that changing gentoo to a single voting body would be good, for simplicity. the complexity and drama introduced by people no liking the idea of the foundation controlling gentoo would be reduced
+Oct 16 15:26:42 <antarus> and mostly involves the infra lead having met you and vetting you personally
+Oct 16 15:26:45 <antarus> which is not super great
+Oct 16 15:26:53 <prometheanfire> it'd allow us to move more swiftly to make change if we wanted
+Oct 16 15:27:50 <antarus> so I think I want to tackle that separately
+Oct 16 15:27:58 <prometheanfire> the main issue I see with the proposal as it stands is forced membership in the foundation (perhaps a default true thing could be used instead)
+Oct 16 15:28:08 <prometheanfire> antarus: tackle the membership docs/issues?
+Oct 16 15:28:09 <antarus> I generally agree that the means we use to control foundation membership is poor
+Oct 16 15:28:35 <antarus> 1) people never leave teh foundation 2) some people never join because they find no value in it
+Oct 16 15:28:55 <prometheanfire> I personally think foundation membership should need two things, 'contribute to gentoo' and 'agree to the coc'
+Oct 16 15:28:55 <antarus> (plus a bunch of other reasons, but its less clear we can combat those with simple membership controls)
+Oct 16 15:29:31 <prometheanfire> 1 is fixed by tying foundation membership to staff membership
+Oct 16 15:29:35 <antarus> I think we could easily pass some bylaws to fix 1 (and some were sent out already)
+Oct 16 15:29:57 <prometheanfire> if staff is retired then foundation membership is revoked
+Oct 16 15:30:02 <antarus> 2 is less clear
+Oct 16 15:30:11 <prometheanfire> as far as people not finding value, ya, that's hard
+Oct 16 15:30:15 <antarus> I don't necessarily want to force people to join the foundation
+Oct 16 15:30:25 <antarus> although it may be necessary for some positions; I'm somewhat open to that idea
+Oct 16 15:30:34 <antarus> (I feel like there is some balance)
+Oct 16 15:30:54 <prometheanfire> I personally think default to joining is fine, with an opt-out
+Oct 16 15:30:55 <antarus> I need more informatoin, specifically from conscienscous objectors who for some reason do not wish to join the foundation ever
+Oct 16 15:31:09 <prometheanfire> no opt-out is hard because members are forced to vote
+Oct 16 15:31:12 <antarus> and so if we forbade them from ever being in say..comrel...
+Oct 16 15:31:17 <antarus> what would that do to the project
+Oct 16 15:32:38 <prometheanfire> ya, I think the discussion should continue, hopefully by next meeting we'll have something actionable
+Oct 16 15:32:52 <prometheanfire> I just wanted to bring it up as something to be noticed
+Oct 16 15:32:55 <antarus> I think the data typically shows that fewer people opt-anything
+Oct 16 15:33:01 <antarus> so opt-in would garner more membership
+Oct 16 15:33:07 <antarus> er out* sorry
+Oct 16 15:33:11 <prometheanfire> right
+Oct 16 15:33:29 <antarus> I think the question i pose is whether we want inactive members
+Oct 16 15:33:32 <dabbott> I would like to see how other distros do it, we may not need to reenvent just copy
+Oct 16 15:33:34 <prometheanfire> the suggestion I like most was 'opt-out with auto opt-out when missing N-votes'
+Oct 16 15:33:56 <antarus> if people 'forget' to opt-out, but never contribute to foundation business
+Oct 16 15:34:02 <antarus> do we actually want them as members?
+Oct 16 15:34:06 * ChanServ gives voice to Bircoph
+Oct 16 15:34:14 <prometheanfire> I have a friend close with fedora I may be able to ask
+Oct 16 15:34:18 <antarus> to me this comes back to the membership being useful in some way
+Oct 16 15:34:28 <prometheanfire> antarus: well, like I said, 'opt-out with auto opt-out when missing N-votes'
+Oct 16 15:34:29 <antarus> which is an argument for moving more stuff under the foundation
+Oct 16 15:34:40 <antarus> prometheanfire: yeah I don't understand what that means
+Oct 16 15:34:43 <antarus> like during voting...?
+Oct 16 15:34:45 <prometheanfire> true, that's an eventual goal
+Oct 16 15:35:01 <antarus> or you mean they automatically lose membership after missing votes?
+Oct 16 15:35:03 <prometheanfire> auto opt-out if you miss an election
+Oct 16 15:35:06 <antarus> ahh
+Oct 16 15:35:11 <prometheanfire> or two
+Oct 16 15:35:18 <antarus> I thought there was some skepticism that that method was effective
+Oct 16 15:35:19 <prometheanfire> as the current rules state
+Oct 16 15:35:33 <prometheanfire> it's better than nothing :|
+Oct 16 15:35:34 <prometheanfire> also
+Oct 16 15:35:50 <antarus> I will perhaps collect some stats
+Oct 16 15:35:53 <antarus> on foundation membership vs staff
+Oct 16 15:35:54 <prometheanfire> tying it to staff would make retirement from staff mean you loose membership
+Oct 16 15:36:01 <antarus> if they leave gentoo, and that makes them leave the foundation
+Oct 16 15:36:11 <antarus> that may be sufficient to keep rolls reflective of active members
+Oct 16 15:36:12 <prometheanfire> staff is an underused position within gentoo atm
+Oct 16 15:36:29 <antarus> AI(antarus) to run some numbers
+Oct 16 15:36:32 <prometheanfire> at least from what I've seen
+Oct 16 15:36:46 <prometheanfire> antarus: want me to say that?
+Oct 16 15:36:56 <antarus> ?
+Oct 16 15:37:05 <prometheanfire> Action Item, antarus - run some numbers
+Oct 16 15:37:06 <antarus> I am perfectly comfortable making AIs for myself, haha
+Oct 16 15:37:09 <prometheanfire> :P
+Oct 16 15:37:18 <antarus> I will run 1 mile in 10 minutes
+Oct 16 15:37:31 <prometheanfire> ok, I'll let that sit for now, next?
+Oct 16 15:37:46 <antarus> dabbott: any other comments specifically on managing foundation rolls?
+Oct 16 15:37:56 <dabbott> no
+Oct 16 15:38:08 <prometheanfire> k, next
+Oct 16 15:38:21 <prometheanfire> Elect President
+Oct 16 15:38:34 <prometheanfire> NeddySeagoon: around? you sent the email so may have a canidate list
+Oct 16 15:38:44 <prometheanfire> I don't remember seeing anyone step forward
+Oct 16 15:38:44 <antarus> candidates were supposed to email trustees@
+Oct 16 15:38:49 <prometheanfire> ya
+Oct 16 15:38:49 <antarus> and afaik I saw 0 entries
+Oct 16 15:38:52 <antarus> minus your IRC entry ;)
+Oct 16 15:38:58 <dabbott> I did not see any reply's
+Oct 16 15:39:08 <prometheanfire> ya, I only volunteered as a backup
+Oct 16 15:39:28 <antarus> bathroom, brb
+Oct 16 15:39:36 <prometheanfire> k
+Oct 16 15:39:39 <prometheanfire> 5 min break
+Oct 16 15:41:28 <NeddySeagoon> alicef may come forward.
+Oct 16 15:42:35 <dabbott> We just have a hard time getting people interested in the foundation, thats why it was researched to turn it over to a co-op but we did not want to lose control of the money etc
+Oct 16 15:42:37 <NeddySeagoon> Other than that, I've had a few messages from well wishers in response to President Wanated
+Oct 16 15:42:49 * antarus is back
+Oct 16 15:43:07 <prometheanfire> !time alicef
+Oct 16 15:43:07 <willikins> prometheanfire: Asia - Tokyo - Mon Oct 17 04:43 JST
+Oct 16 15:43:16 <prometheanfire> bad time to ask
+Oct 16 15:43:38 <NeddySeagoon> I've had a few /query sessions
+Oct 16 15:45:02 <prometheanfire> I'd personally rather not go antoher month without a president, but it may not hurt...
+Oct 16 15:46:48 * ChanServ gives voice to K_F
+Oct 16 15:46:52 <prometheanfire> anyone have any strong opinions?
+Oct 16 15:47:40 <dabbott> We need someone accountable, I would even pay the right person
+Oct 16 15:47:44 <antarus> what do we expect to change
+Oct 16 15:47:48 <antarus> between now and next month
+Oct 16 15:48:22 <prometheanfire> antarus: nothing really?
+Oct 16 15:48:25 <prometheanfire> dabbott: accountable for what?
+Oct 16 15:49:10 <dabbott> To drive the foundation forward
+Oct 16 15:49:27 <prometheanfire> fair enough
+Oct 16 15:49:28 <antarus> The president is basically CEO-esque
+Oct 16 15:49:35 <antarus> so he has an agenda, stuff he wants done, etc
+Oct 16 15:49:35 <dabbott> get stuff done anser to the board
+Oct 16 15:49:55 <antarus> we generally haven't had much of that
+Oct 16 15:50:06 <prometheanfire> which may be part of the problem :P
+Oct 16 15:50:09 <antarus> sure
+Oct 16 15:50:10 <prometheanfire> or not
+Oct 16 15:50:21 <antarus> (this isn't an attack on the previous president or anything)
+Oct 16 15:50:25 <dabbott> we all have real live stuff that takes our time and energy
+Oct 16 15:50:29 <prometheanfire> NeddySeagoon: <3
+Oct 16 15:50:30 <antarus> we appreciate your service NeddySeagoon ;)
+Oct 16 15:50:48 <antarus> I also think Gentoo is not necessarily...receptive to such things
+Oct 16 15:50:59 <prometheanfire> well, the president could switch next month right?
+Oct 16 15:50:59 <antarus> because the foundatoin has very little direct power in the current metastructure
+Oct 16 15:51:05 <prometheanfire> would an interim president work?
+Oct 16 15:51:15 <antarus> and so it would be interesting to see how someone would drive anything from here
+Oct 16 15:51:21 <NeddySeagoon> There is actully little to do other than get our position straight federally and with thu IRS. We have no say in the distro but we take the blame
+Oct 16 15:51:53 <prometheanfire> NeddySeagoon: first part is in progress, second part may be in progress too :P
+Oct 16 15:52:05 <NeddySeagoon> prometheanfire: Yep, I'm aware
+Oct 16 15:52:33 <NeddySeagoon> Nobody driven the IRS :)
+Oct 16 15:52:39 <NeddySeagoon> drives*
+Oct 16 15:52:39 <antarus> well let me put it this way
+Oct 16 15:52:47 <antarus> are we willing ot vote on a president with 3 votes?
+Oct 16 15:52:50 <antarus> or shall we defer?
+Oct 16 15:52:59 <NeddySeagoon> I suggest defer
+Oct 16 15:53:01 <dabbott> lets wait
+Oct 16 15:53:03 <prometheanfire> ya, defer
+Oct 16 15:53:08 <antarus> agreed
+Oct 16 15:53:25 <prometheanfire> NeddySeagoon: get the canidates to email trustees@ with their 'manifesto'
+Oct 16 15:53:32 <prometheanfire> I'll do the same
+Oct 16 15:53:46 <prometheanfire> no other business?
+Oct 16 15:54:12 <NeddySeagoon> I'm not intending to be doing other things until after Christmas. Tonight was just an unplanned late dinner. Sorry for the short notice
+Oct 16 15:54:27 <antarus> did we do bugs?
+Oct 16 15:54:37 <antarus> I feel like we have a lot of them open ;p
+Oct 16 15:54:37 <dabbott> no
+Oct 16 15:54:43 <prometheanfire> no, sorry
+Oct 16 15:54:54 <prometheanfire> open bugs
+Oct 16 15:54:58 <prometheanfire> https://bugs.gentoo.org/buglist.cgi?bug_status=UNCONFIRMED&bug_status=CONFIRMED&bug_status=IN_PROGRESS&bug_status=VERIFIED&email2=trustees&emailassigned_to2=1&emailcc2=1&emailreporter2=1&emailtype2=substring&known_name=TrusteesOpenBugs&list_id=3290194&order=Last%20Changed&query_based_on=TrusteesOpenBugs&query_format=advanced&resolution=---
+Oct 16 15:55:03 <prometheanfire> quite the link
+Oct 16 15:55:15 <NeddySeagoon> a lot of bugs look like thef need an off line review and just closed
+Oct 16 15:55:15 <antarus> Can we close bug 543768
+Oct 16 15:55:18 <willikins> antarus: https://bugs.gentoo.org/543768 "Joining the NTF foundation"; Gentoo Foundation, Proposals; CONF; dabbott:trustees
+Oct 16 15:55:20 <antarus> or do we need a vote?
+Oct 16 15:55:33 <NeddySeagoon> WE voteh to toh join
+Oct 16 15:55:37 <NeddySeagoon> not*
+Oct 16 15:55:40 <prometheanfire> I say nay
+Oct 16 15:55:40 <dabbott> close it I say
+Oct 16 15:55:41 <prometheanfire> close
+Oct 16 15:55:46 <NeddySeagoon> They wanted an NDA
+Oct 16 15:55:49 <prometheanfire> that's quorum :P
+Oct 16 15:55:57 <antarus> aye close
+Oct 16 15:56:02 <prometheanfire> ok, closing
+Oct 16 15:56:04 <antarus> I need to find my bugzilla password ;)
+Oct 16 15:56:13 <dabbott> bug 591704
+Oct 16 15:56:15 <willikins> dabbott: https://bugs.gentoo.org/591704 "commemorate Jon Portnoy (avenj)"; Gentoo Foundation, Proposals; CONF; jer:trustees
+Oct 16 15:56:27 <dabbott> we can close that also
+Oct 16 15:56:31 <prometheanfire> dabbott: I think that's completed as well
+Oct 16 15:56:45 <NeddySeagoon> Complete. We got a thank you that should go on the bug
+Oct 16 15:56:57 <prometheanfire> NeddySeagoon: mind adding that real quick?
+Oct 16 15:57:10 <antarus> https://bugs.gentoo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=473214
+Oct 16 15:57:19 <antarus> once we get mail forwarding they might be able to handle that?
+Oct 16 15:57:25 <prometheanfire> bug 473214
+Oct 16 15:57:28 <willikins> prometheanfire: https://bugs.gentoo.org/473214 "Non-paypal contribution method"; Gentoo Foundation, Proposals; CONF; rich0:trustees
+Oct 16 15:57:31 <NeddySeagoon> I need to find it. its is emails to trustees@
+Oct 16 15:57:41 <prometheanfire> antarus: robbat2 is handling that atm
+Oct 16 15:58:05 <dabbott> I closed bug 591704
+Oct 16 15:58:05 <willikins> dabbott: https://bugs.gentoo.org/591704 "commemorate Jon Portnoy (avenj)"; Gentoo Foundation, Proposals; CONF; jer:trustees
+Oct 16 15:58:11 <prometheanfire> k
+Oct 16 15:58:30 <antarus> did we do 536668
+Oct 16 15:58:32 <antarus> in 2015?
+Oct 16 15:58:34 <antarus> bug 536668
+Oct 16 15:58:36 <willikins> antarus: https://bugs.gentoo.org/536668 "Grammar bug leads to wrong interpretation of social contract"; Websites, Other; CONF; dberkholz:trustees
+Oct 16 15:58:41 <prometheanfire> dabbott: I don't see it closed
+Oct 16 15:59:00 <dabbott> sorry wrong bug, I closed bug 591836
+Oct 16 15:59:03 <willikins> https://bugs.gentoo.org/591836 "NM Annual Filing Fee"; Gentoo Foundation, Filings; RESO, FIXE; dabbott:trustees
+Oct 16 15:59:09 <prometheanfire> ah, k
+Oct 16 16:00:48 <dabbott> I think thats all we can do today
+Oct 16 16:00:52 <antarus> agreed
+Oct 16 16:01:01 <prometheanfire> ya
+Oct 16 16:01:06 <prometheanfire> running over now
+Oct 16 16:01:07 <NeddySeagoon> prometheanfire: I can't find the 'thank you' right now
+Oct 16 16:01:26 <prometheanfire> NeddySeagoon: np, the bug is still open
+Oct 16 16:01:38 <prometheanfire> ok, til next month then...
+Oct 16 16:01:50 <NeddySeagoon> 20 Nov
+Oct 16 16:01:50 <prometheanfire> do we want to get a time for the dec meeting?
+Oct 16 16:02:01 <NeddySeagoon> Its alwayn 19:00 UTC
+Oct 16 16:02:04 <antarus> let me check my dates
+Oct 16 16:02:10 * prometheanfire means date
+Oct 16 16:02:21 <NeddySeagoon> Its the 3rd Sun
+Oct 16 16:02:26 <antarus> ok I am around on nov 20
+Oct 16 16:02:40 <NeddySeagoon> Me too
+Oct 16 16:02:40 <prometheanfire> 17 dec 2016 is fine with me
+Oct 16 16:02:45 <prometheanfire> bah
+Oct 16 16:02:46 <prometheanfire> 18
+Oct 16 16:02:49 <antarus> oh we need to decide dec?
+Oct 16 16:02:58 <antarus> I think I am around until dec 21
+Oct 16 16:02:58 <dabbott> prometheanfire: next meeting in Nov
+Oct 16 16:03:01 <prometheanfire> just to put as a note for the next meeting
+Oct 16 16:03:13 <NeddySeagoon> 18 Dec works for me too
+Oct 16 16:03:18 <antarus> so lgtm without checking my calendar :)
+Oct 16 16:03:23 <prometheanfire> yes, the next meeting is 20 nov, after that is 18 dec
+Oct 16 16:03:28 <prometheanfire> k
+Oct 16 16:03:31 <NeddySeagoon> yep
+Oct 16 16:03:34 <prometheanfire> any other business?
+Oct 16 16:03:34 <dabbott> both fine here
+Oct 16 16:03:49 <NeddySeagoon> One thing from me ...
+Oct 16 16:05:11 <NeddySeagoon> We had received a joint email to trustees and council. It should be acknowleged, probably by council, or it looks like its being ignored. It was on a council topic
+Oct 16 16:05:50 <antarus> is this the email from Ian, or Rich?
+Oct 16 16:05:58 <NeddySeagoon> Neither
+Oct 16 16:06:55 <prometheanfire> talking about the joint work?
+Oct 16 16:07:06 <antarus> I am confused as to which email you are referring then ;p
+Oct 16 16:07:50 <NeddySeagoon> skip it ... I can't find it right now
+Oct 16 16:08:23 <prometheanfire> ok, til next time then
+Oct 16 16:08:40 * prometheanfire bangs the virtual gavel to close this meeting
diff --git a/motions/2016_motions.txt b/motions/2016_motions.txt
index bfd7b31..f0033ba 100644
@@ -12,4 +12,5 @@
fees | approved
2016/9/18 Private Policy Statment | Approved
2016/9/18 Richard Yao (ryao) Membership application | Approved
+2016/10/16 Mauricio Lima Pilla (pilla) Membership application | Approved